New USA Freestyle Scoring System is working very
well and almost completely refined for 2005 season!
June 23, 2004
Freestyle was suffering from a lack of the big
moves being done in competition in the past two years because it
was safer to do the cartwheel moves and rack up technical points
to over power the big tricks scores. In 2004 the USFKA lead by my
wife Kristine, with the input of any freestyle boater that was interested,
Clay Wright, Shane Benedict, Jay Kincaid, and myself scrapped the
technical part of freestyle and focused on “Variety Only”
system. This means that the only thing that scores in freestyle
is individual moves, and you only get scored for a move once. The
harder the move, the more points it is worth. The goal is to have
enough emphasis on the harder moves to make it more attractive to
try to “Go Big” if you want to win, than to “go
small and fast”. In the first event in California, the system
only scored your “top 5 moves”. The move only counted
if you stuck it. What happened was a sad display of everybody doing
the same 5 moves, and taking their sweet time to do them. It was
neither fun or a good competition. Kristine had the 5 move limit
lifted after talking with all participants and at the American Festival
it was a much better event with the whole 45 seconds being used
for moves. However, any Big Move was still too risky to try unless
you were sure you would stick it so the really tough moves still
weren’t happening. Nothing harder than an air loop was even
tried, that was still not achieving our goal.
The next weekend- Bob’s Hole Rodeo was
the breakthrough!!!! A 6 point completion bonus for all moves from
the Air Loop and harder was added. This combined with awarding the
competitor the points for any of the hard moves that they hit, but
flushed on, put enough of an incentive to try the hard moves because
of the high scores you get when you stick them, plus the safety
of at least getting scored for any of the moves completed, even
if they flush. The result: Donkey Flips, Helix, Felix, Air Loops,
Pan Am, Clean Back Stabs, etc. etc. and a very exciting event! As
a competitor, I could start to show my hardest moves during competition
and those competitors who were good at one trick but didn’t
have the full range of hard moves, found themselves training again
to learn the hard moves. Right now is a very exciting time to be
a competitor in Freestyle in the USA!!!
What is a rodeo like now with the new system?
Well, just look at the top three place rides
at Reno, FIBARK, and Bob’s Hole. Before these new rules you
could count on one hand the number of kayakers in the world who
could do moves such as the Lunar Orbit, McNasty, Phonix Monkey,
etc. In the last two weeks, kayakers who are known to be leaders
in freestyle are finding that they have lots of work to do to learn
new moves and be able to hit them in competition. The plateau has
been busted wide open and the curve is going straight up again.
The McNasty is the Air Loop of three years ago. The Lunar Orbit
is the Tricky Woo of three years ago, The Phonix Monkey is the Space
Godzilla of two years ago. And this is just the hole moves. The
same will happen on the wave competitions. Last year doing all of
your air blunts and then getting ends was the best plan for a wave
competition. Now- it is every hard move, and stick it, or lose,
WOW! Want to know who has all of the moves on a wave or in a hole?
Just watch the competitions! What about those athletes that can
do the same hard move but go BIG? We have a “Big” and
a “Huge” bonus that can be added to any of the moves
that have a competition bonus (hard moves).
What is the down side? Right now the IFC (International
Freestyle Committee), which Kristine is Vice-Chair of is not keeping
up to date and it is likely that the upcoming World Championships
will not have this system in place. The Committee wanted the USA
to develop a new system to replace the existing one and everybody
had an opinion of what would work well. Like with anything- a great
idea needs to be developed, tested, and then redeveloped until the
bugs are worked out. The current status of the USFKA system is now
only in need of very minor tuning. The scoring sheets, exact value
of each move, and the method of using the clean, big, or huge bonus
still needs some work when it comes to judge training, etc. If the
Committee acts quickly enough, and votes on it, we could have the
best world championships ever, with people like Andy from Australia
(who did the biggest loops ever) getting credit for his huge moves.
My fear is that the IFC will either not act for this world championships,
or worse, give into the idea of making the world championships a
more “festival atmosphere” and not take the competitive
side of the event seriously enough. There are a group of people
who think our sport is not attractive to the spectators and media.
The primary missing ingredient for spectators is immediate scores,
and the current rank of the athlete, along with the athletes doing
the latest, hardest, most spectacular moves. The new system is perfect
for that, with calculators no longer needed, and the math is simple
addition of the move scores.
Judging: The crazy thing is that athletes that
were competitive last year, but haven’t been around this year,
can’t just sit in and judge without training. The Phonix Monkey
was invented just this year, the McNasty last year, the Lunar Orbit
last year, but all have only been seen in competition for the first
time this year!
Want to see what these moves look like? Click
on these links: I will put up a video of my rides at Salida from
this past weekend if you want to see what a “new school”
rodeo ride looks like. It was my goal in these rides to only do
moves on the top of the list.